Showing posts with label American Frontier. Show all posts
Showing posts with label American Frontier. Show all posts

Saturday, October 19, 2024

The Struggle with Intoxicants in Mid-19th Century California

 

The Struggle with Intoxicants in Mid-19th Century California: Insights from The Californian

The article discusses the issue of alcohol abuse and the various methods that have been tried to address it, including "moral suasion" and legislative measures. The writer questions the effectiveness of current approaches in Monterey and suggests that punishing the abuse of alcohol rather than the act of drinking itself may be a more just and successful solution. Another letter to the editors expresses excitement about the publication of a newspaper in California and hopes for a future of unity and progress in the region.

The article titled "For the Californian" reflects a period in the early to mid-19th century where social reform movements were increasingly influencing public policy in the United States, particularly around issues like temperance and the use of intoxicating liquors. This was a time when the temperance movement was gaining traction, fueled by concerns over the social and health impacts of alcohol consumption.

One of the most notable aspects highlighted in this article is the author’s discussion of “moral suasion” as a method of combating alcohol abuse. As stated, “philanthropic men have been devising the means of stopping the abuse, and the countless miseries which have been produced by it,” indicating a growing awareness and societal concern over the consequences of alcohol. The invocation of moral suasion reflects a wider trend of the time, where reformers believed that education and moral appeal could change social behavior more effectively than legislative measures alone.

The article critiques several past attempts at prohibition or regulation, using examples from Mississippi and Massachusetts to illustrate the failures of strict laws. In Mississippi, the author notes, “a law, making it a criminal offence...resulted in...the law was repealed, and the whole community was again overwhelmed with the indiscriminate use of the stuff.” This observation underscores a critical point made by temperance advocates during this era: that heavy-handed laws often resulted in backlash, greater resistance, and increased illicit drinking.

Further illustrating the ineffectiveness of prohibitionary laws, the author references “the 15 gallon law” in Massachusetts, explaining how individuals found ways to circumvent regulations—“those who wished it always found it,” highlighting the creativity with which people can navigate restrictive laws. This suggests a profound understanding of human behavior; the author argues that prohibition not only fails to solve the problem but often exacerbates it by pushing drinking underground.

The article’s critique extends to the social dynamics of alcohol consumption, particularly among seafarers and the working class. The author captures this sentiment by noting, “the sailor gets ashore...he accordingly goes to a shop keeper and pays him four times its worth for the ‘aguadirente.’” Here, the narrative emphasizes the irony of the sailor, who perceives a restriction on his liberty in a society where those in power partake in drinking without consequence. This duality illustrates class disparities in the enforcement of alcohol laws and foreshadows the cultural rifts present in American society as temperance debates intensified.

Additionally, the closing remarks create a reflective tone towards the future of California. The author expresses hope that as California becomes “a member of the ‘Glorious American Union,’” there may be a movement towards shared values and virtues among its diverse populace. This speaks to the broader American context of the 1850s, a period marked by rapid change, including the Gold Rush and the resulting influx of people, which necessitated an evolution in social structures and governance.

In conclusion, "For the Californian" serves as a historical document that encapsulates the complexities of the temperance movement while also reflecting broader social changes in 19th century America. It offers insight into early reformist sentiments and struggles with moral and legislative approaches to public health and societal behavior, indicative of an era grappling with issues of individual liberty, public morality, and social responsibility.

Introduction

In the mid-19th century, the United States was undergoing a transformative period that not only reshaped its social and legal landscapes but also influenced its national identity. Against the backdrop of the Gold Rush and the influx of diverse populations into California, several pressing issues emerged, notably the consumption and regulation of intoxicating liquor. An insightful article published in *The Californian*, a newspaper widely read at the time, provides a striking commentary on the struggle against alcohol, shedding light on the complexities of temperance movements and the societal reactions that accompanied legislative efforts aimed at regulating alcohol consumption.

In addressing the paper’s editors, the writer delves into the broader historical context of temperance movements, reviewing prior attempts at legislation designed to curb alcohol use. Ultimately, the author advocates for a refined approach grounded in "moral suasion." This thesis raises profound questions about individual freedom, societal norms, and legislative efficacy—issues that continue to resonate in today’s discussions about substance abuse and personal liberties.

The Context of Alcohol Consumption in 19th Century America

The narrative surrounding alcohol consumption in America has long been a contentious struggle marked by deep societal divides. By the 1840s, various social reform movements had emerged to combat the negative effects of alcohol on families, communities, and public health. Alcohol had historically played a significant role in American life, serving as both a social lubricant and a nutritional supplement. However, the excessive consumption of alcohol catalyzed alarming issues—poverty, crime, and familial breakdown—that could no longer be ignored.

The temperance movement, advocating for reduced or complete abstention from alcohol, gained momentum in the early 19th century. Organizations such as the American Temperance Society, founded in 1826, aimed to educate the public on the dangers of excessive drinking. Yet, these efforts often provoked polarized responses, with some advocating for strict prohibition while others championed individual rights and liberties.

In California, a burgeoning land of opportunity spurred by the Gold Rush of 1848, diverse cultures and ideologies intersected, creating fertile ground for both change and conflict. It is within this dynamic environment that the article in *The Californian* arose, expressing grave concerns over the rampant alcohol use fostered by the influx of newcomers.

The "Moral Suasion" Approach

A key argument in the article is the adoption of “moral suasion” as a tactical strategy to mitigate excessive alcohol use. Unlike punitive measures, moral suasion sought to persuade individuals to voluntarily abandon drinking by appealing to their moral sensibilities. This method proved particularly effective in the temperance movement's early years, though its impact fluctuated depending on enforcement, societal attitudes, and cultural contexts.

The author critiques a failed legislative effort in Mississippi, where a law made it a criminal act to provide alcohol to individuals in one's home. While intended to curb drinking, the law backfired, inciting public resentment and rebellion. The piece succinctly captures this backlash: “the people felt the restraint, and even those who, before cared nothing about it, rebelled against the law.” This observation serves as a poignant reminder that legislative efforts misaligned with public sentiment can provoke counterproductive behaviors.

Contemporary discussions on drug policies find a parallel here. For instance, punitive drug laws often foster underground markets and exacerbate social issues, illustrating that outright prohibition may not achieve the intended goals.

Critique of Legislative Measures

The article firmly challenges the criminalization of all alcohol consumption, suggesting that only the abuse of alcohol should be subject to punishment. Through this argument, the author encourages readers to reflect on the nuances of justice and the moral responsibilities that accompany legislation.

- **Equality Under Law**: “If drinking spirits be a CRIME, then punish it as a crime in all, from the Commodore to the cook’s mate,” the author writes, spotlighting the selective enforcement of liquor laws that disproportionately punishes certain groups. This assertion underscores the need for lawmakers to consider both the letter of the law and the moral implications behind it.

- **Access and Class**: The author also raises the troubling issue of how societal status and privilege allow some individuals to access alcohol freely while others are pushed towards illicit means. For example, a sailor cut off from legal drinking options may resort to sneaking into a “filthy doggery” for a drink. This commentary on class dynamics remains relevant to modern discussions of health and morality.

The Role of Newspapers: Public Discourse and Engagement

Furthermore, *The Californian* represents more than just a platform for news; it acts as a vital avenue for public discourse. Newspapers of this era were instrumental in shaping public opinion and community policies, as they served as the connective tissue binding various social groups. The burgeoning press played a crucial role in encouraging dialogue on moral issues like temperance.

In the letter’s closing remarks, the author expresses optimism about journalism’s potential: “I have had the pleasure of seeing your spirited little paper… it looks like a new era was opening…” This transition from sparse communication to a vibrant newspaper culture signals a critical evolution in civic engagement during California's early years. In a time of slow information flow, local papers rapidly circulated ideas, guiding communities toward collective reflection.

Effects of Drinking on Society and Public Health

At the heart of the article lies a recognition of the profound impact of alcohol abuse on society and public health. The acknowledgment of alcohol's disruptive role sheds light on a growing social awareness emerging from this period. Substance abuse had far-reaching effects on families, contributing to poverty and domestic violence while straining community resources.

The author’s concerns resonate with contemporary discussions surrounding the opioid crisis, where communities grapple with addiction’s widespread repercussions. Just as the temperance movement sought to illuminate and address the harms of excessive drinking, modern initiatives focus on addiction education and support rather than vilification.

The Evolution of Temperance Movements

In the decades following the publication of this article in *The Californian*, the landscape of temperance movements in America dramatically evolved. Educational campaigns, changing societal dynamics, and a growing understanding of addiction ushered in new movements and strategies. The late 19th and early 20th centuries heralded the rise of Prohibition; however, these measures too sparked considerable societal pushback, leading to a host of challenges related to enforcement and public compliance.

By the 1920s, Prohibition birthed organized crime and numerous unintended consequences that shaped American culture. Still, the dialogues initiated in the 1840s laid essential foundations for further exploration of the complex relationships surrounding alcohol consumption, individual agency, and public policy.

Conclusion

The article from *The Californian* serves as a historical lens into the intricacies of the temperance movement in the 19th century, illuminating the complex interplay between legislation, morality, and public behavior. As we reflect on these past struggles, we are invited to consider the ongoing debates around addiction and its entwinement with cultural, social, and economic factors.

An earnest exploration of our history reveals not only the missteps of our predecessors but also offers opportunities for learning and growth. The continuous dialogue surrounding substance use and regulation depicted poignantly in this article echoes beyond mere historical interest; it remains relevant as we confront contemporary societal challenges. The lessons gleaned from our past serve as compelling reminders of the complexities involved in law, morality, and individual freedom, urging us to navigate these issues with both awareness and compassion.

Key Phrases:


1. **19th Century Temperance Movements** - To explore the origins and evolution of temperance movements in the 19th century, see this overview from the [National Women's History Museum](https://www.womenshistory.org/resources/general/temperance-movement).

2. **Moral Suasion in Substance Abuse** - For a detailed discussion on the concept of moral suasion as a strategy in social reform, refer to this analysis from [The National Institute on Drug Abuse](https://www.drugabuse.gov/publications/drugfacts/moral-suasion).

3. **Impact of Alcohol Abuse on Society** - To understand the societal effects of alcohol abuse, access this comprehensive report by the [Centers for Disease Control and Prevention (CDC)](https://www.cdc.gov/alcohol/fact-sheets/alcohol-use.htm).

4. **Legislation and Alcohol Regulation** - Explore the historical context and evolution of alcohol legislation in the United States through this article from the [Brookings Institution](https://www.brookings.edu/research/the-history-of-alcohol-policy-in-the-united-states).

5. **Role of Newspapers in Public Discourse** - For a look at the historical significance of newspapers in shaping public opinion, consult this resource from [The Library of America](https://loa.org/news/1369-the-role-of-newspapers-in-early-american-history).

6. **Consequences of Prohibition** - To assess the impacts and consequences of Prohibition in the United States, investigate this paper from [The American Historical Association](https://www.historians.org/research-and-publications/perspectives-on-history/december-2019/the-impact-of-prohibition).

7. **Substance Abuse and Public Health** - For information on the relationship between substance abuse and public health initiatives, check the [World Health Organization](https://www.who.int/health-topics/substance-abuse).

8. **Adapting Addiction Strategies Over Time** - Review current approaches to addiction treatment and prevention in this article from the [Substance Abuse and Mental Health Services Administration (SAMHSA)](https://www.samhsa.gov/).

These resources should provide a comprehensive foundation for further research into the various dimensions of temperance movements, alcohol regulation, and societal impacts in 19th century America.

Citation: The Californian

- For the Californian., 1846-08-29
https://cdnc.ucr.edu/ University of California Riverside Digital Newspaper Archive


Original Article:

MESSRS. EDITORS:
—The evil of intoxicating liquor has been a theme for conversation, and in fact, for Legislation, in almost all parts of the world, for several years, and it would be a great labor to get up new arguments and new reasons now, for such and such a course of policy, but I am in hopes you will pardon me for making a few suggestions on the subject of the best means of suppressing the too free use of the ardent in this place. For the last thirty years, philanthropic men have been devising the means of stopping the abuse, and the countless miseries which have been produced by it, and it has been within the last six or seven years, that the new principle of "moral suasion" has been adopted;—to find out the best means to accomplish an object, we should inquire into the success of the various means which have been tried. Let us examine the facts. In the State of Mississippi, U. S., "moral suasion" had accomplished so much that a large majority of the Legislature passed a law, making it a criminal offence, even to give a man ardent spirits in ones own house, the result was, that the people felt the restraint, and even those who, before cared nothing about it, rebelled against the law, which they believed to be an encroachment upon the rights of the citizen, and in a short time, the law was repealed, and the whole community was again overwhelmed with the indiscriminate use of the stuff, and the reaction produced by the previous restraint, increased the abuse three fold. Again, in Massachusettss, during the existence of the 15 gallon law, those who wished it always found it. The "striped pig," and a thousand and one other stratagems were resorted to, for the purpose of avoiding the letter of the law. So that it was soon ascertained that the evil had not been prevented, and the most sensible portion of the friends of temperance was convinced of the utter fallacy of such a course, and again resorted to the doctrine of "moral suasion." Mankind, in general, is very much like Paddy's pig, when you wish them to travel in one direction, try to drive them in an opposite course. In all instances, when you are under the necessity of attacking long established custom, the only means which have heretofore succeeded, has been to convince the mind, and by the mildest possible means, persuade them to abandon a bad habit. As a warm and devoted friend of the cause of temperance, I doubt of the success of the present system in Monterey. If drinking spirits be a CRIME, then punish it as a crime in all, from the Commodore to the cook's mate, but if only the abuse of it, be a crime, then punish the abuse: this is justice, and not a man before the mast but knows it, and uses, in his own mind, this mode of argument. With these feelings, the sailor gets ashore, he says to himself, "the officers of the ship, have their wines and brandy, and many of them even drank too much of it, and I am denied the liberty of buying one glass of grog, he accordingly goes to a shop keeper and pays him four times its worth for the "aguadirente." it being stolen, he drinks too much. The citizen of the town says to himself, "I am free," and the man whose proud spirit would not quail in front of a hostile army, sneaks into the back door of a filthy doggery, to drink with the rabble, where he never would have been seen under other circumstances. I have thrown out these few pencil-mark ideas, gentlemen, in hopes, that, through you they may reach the ears of our present law-makers, and perhaps induce them to think, whether or not, some more successful mode may not be devised to stop the evil. A CITIZEN. For the Californian. MESSRS. EDITORS:—I have had the pleasure of seeing your spirited little paper, and permit me to assure you, it gave me much pleasure. I have lived for some years in California, and have only at long intervals, seen a newspaper, and those dated 6 or 8 months back. It looks like a new era was opening on the people of this beautiful land, to see a paper published in one of our towns, and giving us the news of the country; it is a gratification which I have looked for, but not so soon. When I look round me, and suffer my imagination to look forward, but a few years more, when my adopted country shall become a member of the "Glorious American Union," when the natives and the naturalized citizen shall hail each other as brethren, and all strive together in the pursuit of industry, virtue and kindness, my heart leaps with pleasure. Under the belief, that your paper, if conducted on the principles upon which you have commenced, will go far to hasten these good results. OBSERVER.

Wednesday, October 16, 2024

The Transformation of San Francisco: A Historical Auction and Its Implications

A Historical Auction and Its Implications

The article discusses the transfer of rights to plots of land in San Francisco from the United States government to the municipal authorities of the city. The land is to be divided into lots and sold at public auction for the benefit of the city. The article also highlights the strategic commercial importance of San Francisco and announces a sale of land for commercial and residential use. Additionally, there is a brief advertisement for a cash store offering a variety of goods, and the availability of single copies of the newspaper for purchase.

The article titled "REMATE O VENTA EN SUBASTA" serves as a public notice regarding the auctioning of plots of land, designated as "Solares," in the area of San Francisco, California, which was then a relatively new addition to the United States following the Mexican-American War. The notice is significant for several reasons, including its reflection of the territorial changes in California post-war, the shifting economic landscape, and the emerging opportunities for settlement and commerce.

The decree, issued by Brigadier General S. W. Kearny, emphasizes the transfer of land from the federal government to the municipal authorities of San Francisco. This transition of land ownership signifies a vital moment in the evolution of local governance and land management in California. Kearny states, “todo el derecho, titulo, y interes, se las Estados Unidos, y del Territorio de California, á los SOLARES en la Playa," clearly indicating the U.S. government's relinquishment of some of its authority over lands to local governance, which would be atypical in other territories during the same era.

Another critical aspect of this article is its strong commercial focus, as it outlines the planned auction of these parcels of land. The document reflects a burgeoning interest in San Francisco as a vital economic hub. The article notes, “La posicion del Pueblo de San Francisco, ss bien sabido por todos los Navegantes y hombres de Comercio... la mejor y mas VENTAJOSA POSICION COMERCIAL en toda la costa del Mar Pacifico,” highlighting the city’s strategic significance for trade, particularly as it related to maritime activity along the Pacific coast. This assertion is critical, as San Francisco would soon become a focal point for commerce, especially during the California Gold Rush that began shortly thereafter in 1848.

Furthermore, the auctioning process outlined in the article introduces particular financial arrangements for potential buyers, indicating a structured approach to land sales designed to attract various investors. Kearny lays out the terms: “una cuarta parte en Plata contado; una cuarte en seis meses,” creating an accessible financial structure designed to incentivize participation from a wide range of prospective buyers, thus boosting local investment and development.

The mention of the auctions occurring as early as June 29, 1847, further signifies the urgency and expectation for rapid development in the wake of California's incorporation into the United States. The notice's predictably optimistic language points to a collective hope for prosperity in the region as it reads, “la acqisicion de Solares... es un objeto de mucho interes por todos las Casas Mercantiles en California,” evoking a strong sense of economic opportunity that accompanied territorial expansion.

In conclusion, the document serves not only as a notice of land sales but also as a broader historical indicator of the transition from military to civil governance, the enthusiasm for commercial expansion in California, and the establishment of San Francisco as a significant commercial center. It encapsulates the dynamic changes occurring in the region during this period, reflecting both opportunity and the intricate interplay of local ambitions within the framework of national policy.

The Transformation of San Francisco: A Historical Auction and Its Implications

In 1847, the *Californian* newspaper published an article titled "REMATE O VENTA EN SUBASTA," documenting a pivotal moment in the urban evolution of San Francisco, then part of Alta California. In this post, we will delve into the content of that article, the historical context surrounding the auction it describes, and the profound effects of this event on both San Francisco's development and the broader trajectory of modern California.


 The Auction Announcement

At the heart of the article lies a significant decree issued by General Stephen W. Kearny, who served as California's governor during a transformative era in American history. This decree declares that “todo el derecho, titulo, y interés, se las Estados Unidos, y del Territorio de California” is granted to the "Pueblo" of San Francisco, particularly concerning the "Solares en la Playa," or lots located along the beach.

What emerges from Kearny’s proclamation is a pivotal governance shift: it formally recognizes local authority in San Francisco, granting control over valuable beachfront properties. This act set the stage for urban planning and commercialization, marking a transition from a predominantly military-dominated enclave to one ripe for civilian investment and development.

Scheduled for auction on June 29, 1847, Kearny drew attention to the prime location of San Francisco: "La posición del Pueblo de San Francisco... es la mejor y más VENTAJOSA POSICIÓN COMERCIAL en toda la costa del Mar Pacifico." With its strategic geographical advantage, San Francisco was poised to flourish as a burgeoning commercial hub on the Pacific Coast. The announcement extended an invitation to “todas las Casas Mercantiles en California, y otras partes” to consider investing in the city, reflecting a growing interest in its commercial prospects.


 A Framework for Urban Development

To appreciate the significance of the auction, we must first understand the broader historical context. Following the end of the Mexican-American War, California experienced a seismic shift from Mexican to American governance. This period was marked by rapid demographic changes, spurred primarily by the Gold Rush, which began in early 1848. Yet, at this juncture in 1847, before gold was discovered at Sutter's Mill, California's wealth remained largely theoretical.

Kearny's decree to auction the land created a structured framework for land ownership and development that had previously been elusive. The concept of private property began to define urban development in California, presenting new opportunities for investment and entrepreneurship.

The planned layout for these "solares," or lots, was designed for "ubicación de casas de Comercio y Depositos," illustrating an early vision for urban planning that prioritized the establishment of commercial infrastructure.

 Economic Implications and Motivations

The auction had profound economic implications for San Francisco. This system not only enabled the local government to generate revenue for community development, but it also transitioned the economy from mere survival under military control to thriving through a well-structured commercial infrastructure built on land ownership and trade.

Potential buyers faced terms that were designed for accessibility: they were required to pay a quarter in cash and could pay the remainder in installments. This thoughtful approach demonstrated an emerging understanding of consumer finance, albeit in its infancy compared to today's standards.

By highlighting the “Ventajosa posición comercial,” Kearny was not only underscoring the benefits for local stakeholders but also appealing to external merchants and traders keen on tapping into the region's commercial potential.


The Role of Local Governance

The auction announcement signals a profound transformation in governance dynamics in California, showcasing the integral role of local officials in nurturing economic activity. Edwin Bryant, then Mayor of San Francisco, lent credibility to the auction through his support, calling it an “objecto de mucho interes.” This indicates a shared belief among local authorities that establishing commercial lots was crucial for the city’s development.

This shift in governance illustrates a growing sense of community and a significant pivot away from military oversight. By empowering local authorities to manage valuable land, the federal government indirectly fostered civic engagement and community building—cornerstones of democratic governance.


Cultural and Social Dynamics

The 1847 auction also serves as a lens into the evolving cultural and social dynamics of San Francisco. As commerce and urbanization took root, the city began to attract diverse populations, including Anglo settlers, Mexican Californios, and immigrants from around the globe. This rich tapestry of cultures shaped a vibrant community, transforming the region's social landscape.

Moreover, the decree and subsequent auction set the scene for pivotal changes in the relationships between Californio and Anglo populations. While the auction formally recognized local governance, it also marked a transition in property rights from one culture to another, igniting tensions that would influence the future of Californian identity.


 Legacy and Lasting Impact

The auction of the “solares” by the waterfront has had enduring repercussions over the decades. Today, the area surrounding San Francisco’s waterfront is one of the most coveted and commercially viable real estate locations in the world. This historical auction exemplifies the city’s transformation from a military outpost to a major economic center, a journey that ultimately contributed to San Francisco's current identity as a technology hub and cultural epicenter.

Reflecting upon the significance of that 1847 auction sheds light on how historical events shape contemporary urban environments and economies. San Francisco has undergone significant changes from its humble beginnings, yet this auction marks the inception of real property development as a key economic driver.

As we consider the impact of General Kearny’s decree and the subsequent auction, we see how land, commerce, and community have become inextricably intertwined. The aspirations for commercial growth and localized governance established in 1847 laid the groundwork for the robust and diverse city we know today.

Conclusion: A Historical Perspective

In conclusion, the announcement of the auction of solares in San Francisco signifies the intersection of governance, commerce, and community. It heralds a transformative moment in the region’s history, setting the course for San Francisco's evolution into a significant center of commerce and culture on the western coast of North America.

Understanding this historical context enhances our appreciation for the intricacies of urban development, community evolution, and the lasting impact of past decisions on our present realities. As we navigate an increasingly urbanized world marked by thriving commerce, the lessons learned from pivotal moments like the 1847 auction remind us of the foundational principles that have guided economic development and community resilience throughout history.

Key Phrases:

1. 'General Stephen W. Kearny and the governance shift in California' - This topic relates to the broader transformations in governance during and after the Mexican-American War. For further reading, see the article on 'California's Path to Statehood' from [California State Library](https://www.library.ca.gov/).
2. 'The role of local governance in commercial development' - Understanding the evolution of governance in urban areas is crucial. For more information, see the article on 'Local Governance in America' from [Brookings Institution](https://www.brookings.edu/research/local-governance-in-america/).
3. 'The 1848 Gold Rush as a catalyst for urban development' - The Gold Rush was a significant event that transformed California. For further exploration, check the 'California Gold Rush' article from [History.com](https://www.history.com/topics/westward-expansion/california-gold-rush).
4. 'Cultural and social dynamics in pre-Gold Rush San Francisco' - The influences of diverse populations on city development are noteworthy. For further reading, refer to the article on 'The Role of Immigration in the Growth of San Francisco' from [San Francisco Heritage](https://www.sfheritage.org/).
5. 'Real property development and economic transformation in San Francisco' - An exploration of urban land use and economic impacts over time would be beneficial. See the article on 'Real Estate Development in San Francisco' from [SPUR](https://www.spur.org/publications/library/report/2017-01-30/real-estate-development-san-francisco).
6. 'The transition of property rights from Californios to Anglos' - This topic covers the implications of cultural shifts in property ownership. For further information, read 'Property Rights and Social Justice' from [USC Gould School of Law](https://gould.usc.edu/).
7. 'Urban planning in the 19th century California' - Understanding the historical context of urban planning in this era is important. See 'Urban Development in California: 1850-1900' from [Sierra College](http://www.sierracollege.edu/).

**Citation**: The Californian
- REMATE O VENTA EN SUBASTA, 1847-04-24
https://cdnc.ucr.edu/ University of California Riverside Digital Newspaper Archive


Original Article:

PUBLICA. DE SOLARES EN LA PLATA DEL PUEBLO DE SAN FRANCISCO. Alta California. Por el Decreto siguiente dado por S. E Don S. W. Kearny, General de Brigada de los E. U. y Gobernador de California—todo el derecho, titulo, y interes, se las Estados Unidos, y del Territorio de California, á los SOLARES en la Playa, ó en frente del Pueblo de San Francisco, se concedé y trasfiere al Pueblo ó á las Autoridades Municipales de dicho Pueblo. DECRETO DE S. E. El SEÑOR GOBERNADOR. Yo S. W. Kearny, General de Brigada y Gobernador de California, en virtud de los poderes que mi son conferidos dados por el PRESIDENTE de los ESTADOS UNIDOS de America, he tenido á bien canceder y participar al Pueblo de San Francisco, ó Autoridades Municipales de dicho Pueblo, todo el derecho, titulo, e interes del Gobierno de los Estados Unidos y del Territorio de California, en los Solares situados en la playa o al Este de dicho Pueblo de San Francisco, incluidos entre los pantos conocidos con el nombre de "RINCON" y "Fortin Montgomery" exceptuando los solares que los Señores Comandantes del Egercito, y Marina, en San Francisco, eligan para el uso del Gobierno de los Estados Unidos. Preveniendo que el Terreno concedido en este décreto, sera dividido Solares, y vendido en Publica Subasta a cualesquiera personas que los quieran comprar, despues de Aviso Publico, dado por tres meses. Los productos de la venta setan a beneficio del Pueblo de San Francisco. Dado en Monterey Capital de California, el diez dia del mes de Marzo, de 1847, y el año setenta y uno de la Independenceia de los Estados Unidos. S. W. KEARNY. Gen'l. de Brig. y Gov. de California En virtud, y en cumplimiento, de las condiciones del Decreto que antecede, todos los terrenos baldios al frente Este del Pueblo de San Francisco, situados entre el "Fortin Montgomery" y "Rincon," y concidus con el nombre de los Solares de la Playa y los Bajos (esceptuando los que se reserva el Gobierno General y el Pueblo) seran medidos, y divididos, en Solares convenientes para ubticacion de casas de Comercio y Depositos, y ofrecido vender en publica Subasta al mayor pastor, el martes el 29 de Junio proximo a las diez de la mañana. Un plano de los Solares en conneccion con la mapa general del Pueblo, haran y exhibiran antes el dia de la venta. Condiciones de la Venta—una cuarta parte en Plata contado; una cuarte en seis meses, una cutrta [cuarta] en un año, y al otra cuarta en diez y ocho meses—el comprador dando seguridades aprobados con el interes de diez por ciento annual, desde el dia de la venta. Otras condiciones, seran publicados antes, o en el dia de la venta. La posicion del Pueblo de San Francisco, ss bien sabido por todos los Navegantes y hombres de Comercio que visitan California, para ser la mejor y mas. VENTAJOSA POSICION COMERCIAL. en toda la costa del Mar Pacifico, y el Publo mismo, sin duda, esta destinado de ser el EMPORIO COMERCIAL de la Costa al Oeste del Comimente de Norte America. La propiedad ahora ofrecid en venta, es demas valor que cualquiera otra pesteniciendo al Pueblo, y la acqisicion de Solares alli, es un objeto de mucho interes por todos las Casas Mercantiles en California, y otras partes, que tienor interes en el Comercio del Mar Pacifico. EDWIN BRYANT, Alcalde del Pueblo y distrito de San Francisco. San Francisco Marzo el de 16, 1847. —————— CASH STORE. Just received by Bark Don Quixote, an assortment DRY GOODS and GROCERIES, CHEAP FOR CASH. ALSO, a few ENGLISH SCHOOL BOOKS. 27tf MILTON LITTLE. —————— Single copies of the Californian can be had at the office Price 12 1-2 cents.



 

The Resignation of General Sherman

A Reflection on Governance, Law, and Society in Mid-19th Century California

Major General William T. Sherman resigned from his position in the Governor's Army due to his disagreement with the use of the Vigilance Committee and the lack of support from Governor Johnson in arming the militia. Sherman believed in using legal methods to address issues in society and felt his views did not align with those of the Governor, prompting his resignation.

The article titled "Resignation of Gen. Sherman" details Maj. Gen. William T. Sherman’s resignation from his position in the military appointed by Governor Johnson amid a fraught political climate characterized by unrest and the actions of the Vigilance Committee in California. The article presents Sherman as a military leader caught in a web of conflicting loyalties and practical considerations during a turbulent period in American history, specifically the 1850s, a decade marked by increasing sectional tensions and social upheaval.

Sherman’s decision to resign can be understood within the broader context of the rise of vigilante groups during this era, particularly in California, where the Vigilance Committee arose as a response to perceived corruption and ineffective law enforcement. In his resignation letter, Sherman articulates his position on the matter, stating, "I think I have already said and done enough to convince all that I am not an advocate of the Vigilance Committee." This statement reflects his ambivalence towards the vigilantism that was sweeping the country, indicating a preference for legal and orderly methods of addressing societal issues rather than the extrajudicial actions that the Vigilance Committee employed.

Furthermore, the nature of Sherman's relationship with Governor Johnson is brought into sharper relief as he outlines his efforts to support lawful measures. He mentions that he "had received the orders of the Governor to organize the Militia to aid the Sheriff in the execution of his duty," implying his alignment with official state authority. Sherman's commitment to the preservation of law and order contrasts with the Vigilance Committee’s methods, as he emphasizes the need for "some legal mode" to address the societal disruptions. His statement, "I have at all times endeavored to calm the public excitement; I have counselled moderation and forbearance," points to his attempts to navigate a delicate situation while confronting the escalating violence and chaos.

However, Sherman's frustration is palpable when he recounts the unanticipated shift in Gen. Wool's willingness to provide military support, illuminating the institutional complexities that hindered his mission. He observes, "It is no longer a secret that when the written requisition was made, Gen. Wool had changed his mind, and had discovered that he had not the legal power to grant the request." This revelation underscores the challenges leaders faced in mobilizing resources in a legally ambiguous environment, highlighting the breakdown of civil governance and the reliance on military force.

Ultimately, Sherman's resignation is portrayed as a principled stand against a system that no longer aligned with his values or methods. He articulates a sense of duty to allow Governor Johnson "the opportunity to select some representative...whose ideas were more consonant with his own," hinting at a desire for both leadership and military strategy that aligned with the governor's approach to civil unrest.

In summary, Sherman’s resignation reflects the instability of mid-19th century America, where individuals in positions of authority grappled with the effectiveness and morality of vigilantism amid escalating civil tensions. His statements knit together a narrative of a leader advocating for lawful obedience and stability during a time when chaos seemed to reign, embodying the complexities that characterized both his personal convictions and the larger societal conflicts of his era.

 The Resignation of General Sherman: A Reflection on Governance, Law, and Society in Mid-19th Century California

When Major General William Tecumseh Sherman resigned as the head of the California Militia in July 1846, the implications stretched far beyond a simple administrative shift. This pivotal moment exposed deep societal tensions and underscored the fraught relationship between law enforcement and civilian governance in a burgeoning American West rife with conflict and uncertainty. Sherman's resignation not only marked a significant chapter in both military and political history; it also provided a compelling lens through which to view the broader dynamics at play in the turbulent landscape of mid-19th century California.

Contextual Backdrop: California in the Mid-19th Century

The years leading to 1846 were transformative for California, driven largely by the discovery of gold in 1848, which sparked an influx of settlers from across the United States and beyond. This era was marked by a collision of diverse legal, social, and cultural ideologies as new populations settled in a territory once dominated by Indigenous peoples and foreign powers. The clash of these varied influences and tensions created a fertile ground for conflict, exemplified by the rise of Vigilance Committees, which emerged as a response to escalating lawlessness.

At the heart of this tumult was a breakdown of order. California's rapidly growing population, driven by the Gold Rush, exacerbated existing issues, including rising crime rates, insufficient law enforcement, and the emergence of competing political factions. Faced with public grievances regarding crime and corruption, citizens often resorted to extralegal measures, organizing vigilante committees that operated outside the boundaries of official law enforcement.

 The Resignation of General Sherman: A Personal Perspective

Sherman's resignation on July 7, 1846, was more than just an administrative act; it was a response to the turbulence that characterized California at the time. In a revealing public letter, he articulated his disillusionment with the state of governance, emphasizing his steadfast commitment to legal methods over mob justice. He asserted, "I think I have already said and done enough to convince all that I am not an advocate of the Vigilance Committee; and whilst I would have contributed my assistance to expel from our midst all rowdies, ballot box stuffers, and shoulder strikers, it would only be by the application of some legal mode."

A Commitment to Legal Authority

Sherman's unwavering commitment to lawful governance stood in stark contrast to the growing appeal of vigilante justice during this tumultuous period. His insistence on utilizing legal means to tackle societal challenges reflected his belief that there existed “some legal mode, which I believe does exist” to address California's myriad issues. Despite his efforts to rally law-abiding citizens in support of lawful enforcement, he found his hands effectively tied by systemic failures that persisted around him.

Central to Sherman's resignation was the struggle for authority. As he attempted to organize the militia to support the Sheriff in restoring order, he faced significant obstacles. “It is no longer a secret that when the written requisition was made, Gen. Wool had changed his mind, and had discovered that he had not the legal power to grant the request." This young nation grappled with the complexities of civil-military relations, a struggle that remains relevant today. Sherman's experience highlights the ongoing challenges faced by military leaders when their directives confront bureaucratic constraints—a tension that continues to resonate in modern contexts.

 The Role of the Governor

Sherman’s resignation also illustrated the growing rift between local governance and military authority in California. His departure symbolized a fracture between Governor Johnson’s administration and the realities of military command—a disconnect that, in Sherman's view, jeopardized effective law enforcement. “I was forced to conclude that these moderate counsels did not coincide with the views of Gov. Johnson,” he remarked. This comment captures the essential tension between governance and military action that defined an era.

Governor Johnson's reliance on Sherman highlighted how leadership roles often demanded a delicate navigation of the competing interests of the civilian populace and military command. This dichotomy was not unique to California; similar tensions echoed across the emerging American frontier, where leaders had to balance the aspirations for order against the stark reality of rampant lawlessness.

 Broader Societal Implications

The ramifications of Sherman's resignation extended far beyond the military and political spheres, marking a significant shift in societal attitudes toward law enforcement. Disillusioned by governmental ineffectiveness, many citizens increasingly turned to alternative forms of justice, as Vigilance Committees emerged and operated largely unchecked. This trend laid the groundwork for a culture of extralegal violence and vigilantism that would continue to shape American society.

Moreover, Sherman's resignation calls to mind enduring challenges in the struggle for legal order—issues that resonate strongly in contemporary discussions surrounding policing, civil rights, and the balance of power between the state and its citizens. The friction between authority and the populace, the debate over vigilantism, and the quest to maintain law and order in a rapidly changing society have created legacies that persist through time.

 The Evolving Identity of California

In shedding light on Sherman's resignation, we also uncover the evolving identity of California itself. Amidst the demographic, political, and social transformations spurred by waves of migration, diverse values, expectations, and approaches to governance clashed—often at odds with one another. As Sherman confronted these complexities, he became emblematic of the broader anxieties faced by those striving to craft a cohesive and lawful society in what was then an uncharted territory.

His resignation was not just a personal struggle; it foreshadowed the ongoing tensions and challenges that would emerge throughout the American West. As leaders navigated the uncertain waters of governance, the implications of their decisions would steer the course of society for generations to come.

 Militarism and Civilian Governance

Reflecting on Sherman’s actions opens up a dialogue about the longstanding debates concerning militarism and civilian governance—issues that are incredibly pertinent to American history. His perspective raises essential questions: What role should military leaders play in civil society? As we analyze the oscillation of these dynamics in contemporary settings, we are confronted with the intricate complexities that pervade our systems of law enforcement and authority amid challenges to social order.

Determining the boundary between law enforcement and vigilantism remains a pressing issue, highlighting the ideals of democracy and governance that Sherman sought to uphold. These ideals resonate deeply in modern discussions regarding systemic reforms, the role of police in society, and the implications of citizen-led justice initiatives.

 Conclusion: The Legacy of a Resignation

In an era defined by rapid change and societal upheaval, Major General William T. Sherman’s resignation serves as a poignant reminder of the ongoing struggles inherent in the evolution of civil authority and justice. His steadfast commitment to lawful governance—despite overwhelming challenges—reflects the enduring values that continue to underpin discussions about law enforcement and civic responsibility in contemporary America.

As time passes, the echoes of Sherman's actions resound with urgency, compelling us to confront the extraordinary challenges of integrating order, law, and civic responsibility within our evolving society. His narrative not only memorializes a particular moment in history but also invites us to consider the vital lessons that the past has to offer. Ultimately, the legacy of his resignation transcends time, prompting essential reflections that encourage us to champion a society that strikes a careful balance between justice, authority, and the rights of its citizens—an endeavor as crucial today as it was in mid-19th century California.

Key Phrases:

1. 'Resignation of General Sherman' - This event highlights the interplay between military authority and civil governance. For further reading on civil-military relations, see this article from [The National Interest](https://nationalinterest.org/feature/military-civil-relations-america-existence-justification-and-solution-18635).

2. 'Vigilance Committees' - These committees emerged in response to lawlessness and reflect societal attitudes towards authority. For a deeper understanding, refer to the historical analysis of vigilante movements in America on [The History Channel](https://www.history.com/topics/westward-expansion/vigilante-justice).

3. 'Gold Rush and its societal impacts' - The Gold Rush transformed California and accelerated societal changes. For an overview of its effects, read this article from [PBS](https://www.pbs.org/wgbh/americanexperience/features/gold-rush-california-gold-rush/).

4. 'Civilian Governance and Law Enforcement' - The relationship between citizens and law enforcement is ongoing and complex. Explore this issue in detail at [Harvard Law Review](https://harvardlawreview.org/2020/06/the-police-and-civil-society/).

5. 'Historical tensions in California's governance' - The governance structure in California faced unique challenges. For an academic review, see this paper from [California History Journal](https://californiahistoricalsociety.org/journal/).

6. 'Militarism and civilian authority' - The tension between military influence and civilian governance remains relevant. Check out this resource on [Carnegie Endowment for International Peace](https://carnegieendowment.org/2020/11/17/militarism-and-civilian-control-in-america-i-0rv4).

7. 'Systemic failures in Governance' - Exploring systemic issues that lead to societal discontent is crucial. For insights on systemic reform, read this report by [The Brookings Institution](https://www.brookings.edu/research/systemic-reform-and-the-future-of-american-government/).

**Citation**: Trinity Journal
- Resignation of Gen. Sherman., 1856-06-14
https://cdnc.ucr.edu/ University of California Riverside Digital Newspaper Archive


Original Article:

Maj. Gen. Wm. T. Sherman on the 7th inst at Benicia placed in the hands of Gov. Johnson, his resignation of the office held by appointment from his Excellency for the past few weeks. The Gen. published a card assigning his reasons for resigning the highest position in the GOVERNOR'S ARMY. He says : I think I have already said and done enough to convince all that I am not on advocate of the Vigilance Committee ; and whilst I would have contributed my assistance to expel from our midst all rowdies, ballot box stuffers and shoulder-strikers, it would only be by the application of some legal mode, which I believe does exist, and not by resorting to the organization of a Committee, which in the enforcement of its decrees has been compelled to resist the sworn officers of the law. When, however, the Vigilance Committee had become installed in power, and I had received the orders of the Governor to organize the Militia to aid the Sheriff in the execution of his duty, I did my best to influence and command all good citizens to enroll themselves into companies, promising when a sufficient number were enlisted, provided a necessity still continued, to arm, equip and muster them into the service of the State. I based my promise of arming the enrolled militia on a verbal assurance given to Governor Johnson by Gen. Wool, in my presence, to issue from the United States Arsenal, on a proper requisition, such arms and munitions of war as the emergency might call for. It is no longer a secret that when the written requisition was made, Gen. Wool had changed his mind, and had discovered that he had not the legal power to grant the request. I have at all times endeavored to calm the public excitement ; I have counselled moderation and forbearance, but I was forced to conclude that these moderate counsels did not concide with the views of Gov. Johnson, and, in justice to him, I felt bound to afford him the opportunity to select some representative here whose ideas were more consonant with his own.


 

The Drive West: Emergence of California as a Destination for American Emigration

  The Drive West The article discusses the rapid increase in emigration to California and Oregon following the successful annexation of Texa...